Skip to content

The Top 5 Pizza Places in Columbus: A 614 Digital Ranking

When it comes to pizza, Columbus has no shortage of incredible options. At 614 Digital, we’ve taken it upon ourselves to rank the best pizza places in the city, ensuring you know where to go for your next cheesy, delicious slice. Here’s our definitive list of the top 5 pizza places in Columbus.

1. JT’s Pizza & Pub

The Ultimate Pizza Experience

JT’s Pizza & Pub takes the crown for the best pizza in Columbus. Known for its warm, inviting atmosphere and a menu that caters to all tastes, JT’s is a local favorite for good reason.

JT’s Pizza & Pub offers a variety of pizzas, from classic pepperoni to more adventurous options like the BBQ Chicken or Buffalo Chicken pizzas. Their dough is perfectly crisp, the toppings are generous, and the flavor is unparalleled.

Why JT’s Stands Out

  • Quality Ingredients: JT’s uses only the freshest ingredients, ensuring every bite is bursting with flavor.
  • Variety: With options ranging from traditional to innovative, there’s something for everyone.
  • Ambiance: The pub setting is perfect for a casual night out with friends or family.

For more information, check out their website: JT’s Pizza & Pub

2. Adriatico’s

A Beloved Campus Classic

Adriatico’s is a staple in Columbus, especially beloved by Ohio State University students and alumni. This pizza place is renowned for its thick, hearty crust and generous toppings.

Adriatico’s serves up both deep-dish and thin-crust pizzas, catering to all preferences. Their Buckeye pizza, loaded with pepperoni and sausage, is a must-try for anyone new to this Columbus gem.

What Makes Adriatico’s Special

  • Signature Crust: Their thick, doughy crust is a standout feature.
  • Hearty Toppings: Adriatico’s doesn’t skimp on toppings, ensuring every bite is satisfying.
  • Community Favorite: Its proximity to OSU and long-standing presence make it a beloved spot for locals.

Visit their website for more details: Adriatico’s

3. Dewey’s Pizza

Gourmet Pizzas for the Discerning Palate

Dewey’s Pizza offers a gourmet pizza experience with unique flavors and high-quality ingredients. Located in the heart of Columbus, Dewey’s is known for its creative toppings and impeccable service.

Their menu features a variety of specialty pizzas, like the Edgar Allan Poe with mozzarella, fontina, mushrooms, Kalamata olives, and roasted garlic, and the Socrates’ Revenge, which includes spinach, black olives, feta, and red onions.

Dewey’s Distinctive Features

  • Creative Menu: Dewey’s offers a variety of gourmet pizzas that go beyond the traditional.
  • Quality Ingredients: Only the finest ingredients make it onto a Dewey’s pizza.
  • Excellent Service: The staff at Dewey’s are known for their friendly and efficient service.

Discover more about Dewey’s on their website: Dewey’s Pizza

4. Grandad’s Pizza

A Family Tradition

Grandad’s Pizza has been serving the Columbus community with love and tradition for years. Known for its no-nonsense approach to pizza, Grandad’s focuses on delivering consistently delicious pies that keep customers coming back.

Their pizzas are known for their perfect balance of crust, sauce, and toppings. Whether you prefer a classic cheese pizza or something more loaded like their Meat Lovers, Grandad’s has you covered.

Why Grandad’s is a Must-Try

  • Consistency: Grandad’s delivers consistently great pizza every time.
  • Family-Owned: This family-run establishment brings a personal touch to every order.
  • Value: High-quality pizza at a reasonable price point.

Learn more about Grandad’s Pizza here: Grandad’s Pizza

5. Harvest Pizzeria

Fresh, Local, and Delicious

Harvest Pizzeria rounds out our top 5 list with its commitment to fresh, local ingredients and unique flavor combinations. Each pizza is crafted with care, using seasonal produce and artisanal techniques.

Harvest Pizzeria offers a range of options, including the classic Margherita and the more adventurous Spicy Yuma, which features chorizo, chipotle-spiked tomato sauce, and jalapeños.

Highlights of Harvest Pizzeria

  • Local Ingredients: Harvest sources many of its ingredients locally, supporting nearby farmers and ensuring fresh flavors.
  • Unique Pizzas: Their menu features both classic and innovative pizza options.
  • Cozy Atmosphere: The inviting ambiance makes it a great spot for a relaxed meal.

Visit their website to explore their menu: Harvest Pizzeria

Conclusion

Columbus is home to some truly outstanding pizza places, each offering something unique and delicious. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic slice or something more gourmet, our top 5 picks have got you covered. From the unbeatable atmosphere at JT’s Pizza & Pub to the fresh, local flavors at Harvest Pizzeria, you can’t go wrong with any of these choices.

At 614 Digital, we pride ourselves on knowing the best local spots, and we hope this list helps you discover your new favorite pizza place in Columbus. Enjoy your slice!