Skip to content

Should I Use Pay-Per-Click or Local Service Ads on Google?

Table Of Contents
  1. Should I Use Pay-Per-Click or Local Service Ads on Google?

Deciding where to invest your online advertising budget can be challenging for a local business. Google offers multiple ways to reach customers, and two popular options are Pay-Per-Click (PPC) ads and Google’s Local Service Ads (LSAs). Both can generate leads, but they work very differently. In this post, we’ll break down the key differences and help you decide should I use Pay-Per-Click or Local Service Ads on Google. By the end, you’ll understand which approach (or combination) makes the most sense for your business.

Should I use Pay-Per-Click or Local Service Ads on Google?

Understanding Pay-Per-Click (PPC) Advertising on Google

PPC ads (through Google Ads) are the traditional text ads you see in search results. You bid on keywords, and you pay a fee each time someone clicks your ad. PPC offers a lot of control – you choose the keywords, write the ad copy, and decide when and where the ads show. It’s a powerful way to drive traffic, but it can also become costly if not managed well. Many businesses work with an Internet Advertising Company that provides Paid Advertising Services to optimize their PPC campaigns and improve return on investment.

What Are Google Local Service Ads (LSAs)?

Google Local Service Ads are a special ad format for local service providers (plumbers, lawyers, contractors, etc.). They appear at the very top of search results (above the regular PPC ads) and show your business name, phone number, rating, and a “Google Guaranteed” badge if you pass Google’s vetting. The key difference is you pay per lead instead of per click – you’re only charged when someone calls or messages you through the ad. You also don’t need to pick keywords; Google will display your LSA for searches related to your services in your area. To run LSAs, your business must pass Google’s screening (background checks, license verification) to earn that trust badge.

What is the Difference Between Google Ads and Google Local Service Ads?

Google Ads (the PPC platform) and Local Service Ads have several key differences. For anyone wondering should I use Pay-Per-Click or Local Service Ads, it’s important to understand how they differ:

  • Payment Model: Google Ads charges per click (PPC), whereas Local Service Ads charge per lead (you pay only when someone calls or messages you).
  • Placement: Google Ads appear as text ads typically below the Local Service Ads section, whereas LSAs appear at the very top of the search results with a “Google Guaranteed” badge.
  • Targeting: With Google Ads, you bid on keywords and can adjust targeting (location, time, etc.). With LSAs, you don’t bid on keywords at all – Google shows your ad for relevant searches in your service area.
  • Control: Google Ads gives you control over your ad copy and landing pages. LSAs are more automated; you have a profile listing, but you can’t customize the ad text beyond that.
  • Eligibility & Trust: Any business can use Google Ads, but only certain industries can use LSAs (and they require background checks and verification). In return, LSAs display a trust indicator (“Google Guaranteed” or “Screened”) that regular PPC ads don’t have.
  • What Happens When Clicked: A Google text ad click sends the user to your website. A Local Service Ad triggers a phone call or message to your business and keeps the interaction on Google’s platform (no visit to your site necessary).

Are Google Local Service Ads Worth It?

Absolutely. For many local businesses, Google Local Service Ads are worth it because they deliver high-quality leads at a lower cost per lead than traditional PPC ads. You only pay for actual customer inquiries, so your budget goes further. The top-of-page placement and Google Guaranteed badge also add credibility – people in need of an urgent service often prefer the provider with that green checkmark and strong reviews.

We’ve seen this firsthand at 614 Digital. Several of our clients’ LSAs have generated more leads (at a lower cost per lead) than their PPC campaigns. Another perk: you can dispute spam or unrelated leads and avoid paying for them, which isn’t possible with standard PPC. To get the best results, you’ll still need a solid Google Business Profile (plenty of good reviews and quick response to inquiries) because Google rewards businesses that keep customers happy.

There are some caveats: If your company has very few reviews or a poor rating, LSAs might not perform as well until you improve your reputation. Also, not every industry is eligible for Local Service Ads. If Google doesn’t offer LSAs in your field (or if you serve a broader national market), then you’ll need to lean more on PPC or Local SEO in Columbus and other marketing strategies. Overall though, if you’re eligible, trying out Local Service Ads is highly recommended given their potential ROI.

How to Get More Leads on Google Local Service Ads

Once your LSAs are running, keep these best practices in mind:

  • Complete Your Profile: Fill out all your business details in the LSA dashboard (services, service area, hours, etc.) and make sure your Google Business Profile is verified. (Even without a public address, you can verify it – see Verifying Your Google Business Profile Without a Traditional Business Address in 2025.) A complete, verified profile will help your ads show up more.
  • Earn Great Reviews: Ask your happy customers to leave Google reviews. A high star rating with a decent number of reviews will boost your LSA ranking and encourage more customers to choose you.

Should I Use Pay-Per-Click or Local Service Ads? Why Not Both?

For many businesses, the best approach is to use both. LSAs capture the high-intent local customers who need your service immediately, while PPC lets you target additional keywords and broader audiences. By running both, you maximize your presence and ensure no potential customers slip through the cracks.

Should I Use Pay-Per-Click or Local Service Ads on Google? Our Recommendation

In summary, if your business is eligible for Local Service Ads, you should certainly use them. LSAs give you top-of-page visibility with a built-in trust factor, and you only pay when a real customer contacts you. It’s one of the most efficient ways to generate local leads.

That said, don’t overlook Pay-Per-Click advertising. A well-run PPC campaign can cover things LSAs might miss – such as targeting specific non-local keywords, promoting special offers, or driving traffic to your website for broader awareness. In an ideal scenario, using both PPC and LSAs will yield the best results. LSAs will deliver steady, high-intent leads, and PPC can expand your reach and support your other marketing objectives. By testing and tuning both channels, you can find the perfect balance to maximize your leads and return on investment.